Date |
Competition |
Opponents |
H/A |
Result |
Score |
24/06/2013 |
League |
Rochdale |
A |
Lost |
1-5 |
03/07/2013 |
League |
Denton |
A |
Draw |
3-3 |
30/07/2013 |
League |
Stockport |
H |
Lost |
½-5½ |
06/08/2013 |
League |
3Cs |
H |
Won |
4-2 |
12/08/2013 |
Cup |
Oldham |
A |
Lost |
2-4 |
27/08/2013 |
League |
Chorlton |
H |
Lost |
1-5 |
03/09/2013 |
League |
Marple |
H |
Lost |
2½-3½ |
After finishing next to the bottom of the league in 2010 and next to the top in 2011, we followed this up with a championship performance in 2012 with 5 wins out of 5. We therefore decided to make a return to the top flight for the first time since 2004. Looking back to those days, it is interesting to note that our regular top 3 that season comprised Jonathan Fish, Daniel Sullivan and Dave Bryan. The top boards of the top division is a tough place in which to play and that year none of them tasted victory and they amassed just 2½ points from the 10 games they played. Our replacements in 2013, namely Yaroslav, Reg and Karl, managed to play 13 matches but still scored only 2½ points, although Karl had the pleasure of tasting victory against 3Cs. Although the final table is not yet available**, it is almost certain that we will return to the happier hunting ground of Division B next summer, given that 4 of the other 6 teams attained more points than us from the first half of their season and one of the other two teams is a strong Marple side. Denton, who drew with us earlier in the season, is our only hope of avoiding the drop.
**Subsequent to this report, the final league table shows that we did not in fact finish bottom, so should again be in the A division next summer.
Our season began with a league match rather than the normal cup fixture, as Heywood decided to drop out of the tournament at the last minute enabling us to progress to the quarter finals. I missed the first match and Reg filled in as captain but only he and Steve Douglas were able to draw in a heavy opening defeat. I was back for the next match at Denton, where I had a wonderful game until it all fell apart right at the end, a defeat that could prove costly given that David Hughes won his game and the other 4 team members drew to enable us to half the match. The next game was another heavy defeat 5½:½ to Stockport, but this was followed up by a 4:2 victory over 3Cs, assisted by 2 defaults, a swindle by Nick and Karl's impressive victory on board 2. Buoyed by this victory we had a very close cup match at Oldham, losing 4:2 in a match where many of the games were closely contested. Nobody won in our next league match against Chorlton to whom we lost 5:1 and the season ended with another defeat 3½:2½ to Marple. Our final league tally of 1 win and 1 draw from 6 matches was similar to 2004 where we also had one win and one draw from the five matches played that season.
We were able to call upon the services of 13 members to play matches, and Steve Ward was only denied the 14th slot by 3Cs default. Last year nearly all 7 players who played 3 or more matches scored 50% or more and 3 totalled 4 points from their games, whereas this year only one of the seven playing 3 games or more managed 50%, being Bill McCartney with 2 wins from 4, and nobody exceeded the 2½ points I obtained from my 6 matches. Nick matched Bill's score of 2 points from his 5 matches and David Hughes and Richard White both had the satisfaction of winning during the season. Other members supporting us during the season were Tom, Callum, Steve, Wayne and David Merrifield.
Thanks as always go to all the team members and in particular, providers of transport to the away matches. I trust we can get back to winning ways again next season.
Tony Lane
24 September 2013
2012 Team captain's report
Our performances in the summer league in recent years have been a real rollercoaster ride. In 2009, we finished second and politely declined promotion to division A. In 2010 a league resolution was passed at the AGM to promote and relegate one team only rather than two. That was fortunate for ourselves as we finished next to bottom with our narrow victory over Chorlton 4 resulting in relegation for our opponents and a narrow escape for ourselves. However, 2011 saw us finish once more as runners up, albeit with no automatic promotion. I am pleased to report that our rollercoaster did not see another dip in performance in 2012.
The season began very encouragingly, when we defeated Oldham’s first team in the cup 4½:1½ despite being heavily out-graded. We were therefore feeling very confident going into our opening league match against Oldham’s second team, as boards 4 and 5 from the first match were their top 2 boards in the league game. Our confidence was not misplaced and we emerged 5:1 winners. A reverse scenario followed with a league match against Stockport 2 succeeded by a cup semi-final against Stockport’s first team. Although we won our league match 3½:2½, cup glory proved beyond our reach against a very strong Stockport team, where David Hughes saved us from a whitewash with a fine win on the bottom board. Following our cup exit we were able to concentrate on the league. The next match was at home to Bury, but unfortunately I only found out on the Tuesday of the match that they were still under the impression we played our home games on a Thursday. Two of our players were unable to play that day but we hastily rearranged the match for the Thursday with a slightly weakened team. However, our squad showed the strength and depth of our resources, and with 3½ points from the bottom 4 boards we were able to retain our 100% league record. Our last 2 games were again against a single club, firstly Chorlton 4 and then Chorlton 3. The first match at Chorlton was a resounding 4½:1½ victory. This meant we went into the last match with both teams on a maximum 8 points 4 points clear of the field. However, Chorlton had a better board count by the narrowest ½ point margin. We therefore needed to win to secure the title. The game proved to be a splendid team effort with 3 wins and 3 draws securing the title. There is now a feeling that after 8 successive years in Division B we should take our place again in Division A.
Eleven members of the club were able to share in our success. Our squad strength was demonstrated by the fact that all 4 players playing 1 or 2 games during the season won all their matches. In 2011, Reg had played 3 matches without any success. This year he played 3 and won the lot. David Hughes was only slightly behind him winning 2 of his 3 matches. Of those players turning out on more than 3 occasions in the season, Bill McCartney was the top percentage scorer with a two third success rate from his 6 matches and his top score of 4 points was matched by Yaroslav and myself, the 2 ever present members of last season. It was good to see Nick back in action, chipping in with 3 draws towards the end of the season. Finally, Tom secured a 50% success rate from the 6 matches in which he played, and his matches remain the ones to watch at the end of the time control as he continued to produce amazing swindles against his opponents.
My thanks therefore go to all those members who brought us such a successful summer season, and of course to the usual regular drivers who assist with transport arrangements in our away matches.
Tony Lane
2011 Team Captain's Report
In 2009 we finished second in Division B and requested not to be promoted due to the significant playing strength difference of the top two divisions. From our point of view, the decision proved to be well justified, as last year we struggled to survive in our normal Division B setting. Our decision also influenced the passing of a league resolution at the 2010 AGM to promote and relegate one team only rather than two. This also avoids wholesale changes in league composition, given that there are now typically four divisions of only five or six clubs. If the rules had not been changed in this manner, we would have been relegated last year, as our sole victory by the narrowest single point margin was over Chorlton 4 who were duly relegated. They were replaced by Bramhall and East Cheshire, but a request by Bury to drop down a division resulted in second place Denton being promoted to Division A to replace them.
As often is the case, the season started with a cup match, and we justified our billing as favourite at Urmston by winning 3½:2½. This was followed by our first league match at Chorlton against their third team, where a 4:2 win ensured we equalled our points tally for 2010 after completing our first league match. I then repeated the mistake made in earlier years of taking a summer holiday and entrusting captaincy of the next match to Nick, who duly advised me on my return that we had been defeated 3½:2½ by Stockport 2. However, we were soon back on track with our next fixture against Bramhall and East Cheshire which was a newly merged club in 2010. Their entry to the Summer league last year had not only seen them gain promotion with an unbeaten record, but saw them also inflict our heaviest defeat in the cup by the margin 5:1. It was therefore nice to gain revenge this year with a 5½:½ victory, albeit assisted by the fact that they were only able to compete on 4 boards and defaulted the other 2. Our most emphatic victory was followed by our most emphatic defeat 5:1 to Denton in the semi finals of the cup and the season finished with a draw at Bury. When I first put pen to paper, our 5 points from 4 league matches placed us a point clear of Chorlton 3 and Stockport 2 at the top of the division. If they were to draw their outstanding match then we would finish as champions in the unlikely event of Bramhall and East Cheshire defeating Stockport 2 in their other outstanding fixture. This appeared unlikely, as BEC had lost their other three matches to date and gained only 3½ points from an available 18. Indeed, I can now confirm following an update of the MCF website last Sunday, that Stockport won both their matches leaving us 3 points adrift of them as runners up and guaranteeing us Division B chess again next summer.
As was the case last year, 10 members played during the season. Although Karl had asked to be rested for the summer, we were strengthened by Yaroslav’s debut in the summer league. He missed the opening cup match at Urmston but played the remaining 5 games on top board. In the penultimate game he defeated the 190+ rated Ali Jaunooby who had recently played in the British Championships. The win was particularly satisfying as he had narrowly missed out in a close match between them in the Manchester League earlier in the year. It was therefore surprising that Yaroslav lost his last match at Bury and with it his 100% record for the season. However, I am delighted to report that this enabled me to draw level with him as top scorer with 4 out of 5 following my win at Bury on Board 2. Bill also played 5 matches and finished with a respectable 50%. Nick had a tough season on Board 2 with his 4 matches producing a draw. Of the 4 players completing 3 games, David Hughes was the most successful with 2 points, Callum had a 50% record, Richard had a crushing victory against BEC and another debutant, Reg, found that first point elusive. I played Reg on top board in the cup at Urmston, Nick played him in the middle at Stockport and he played on the bottom board in the cup against Denton, but sadly we failed to find his best position. I suspect that he is looking forward again to playing in the Manchester league with its more sedate time control. Tom followed up his 100% success of last year with a second unbeaten season from the 2 matches he played and David Merrifield stepped in at the last match at Bury to secure an honourable draw.
My thanks to all those members who shared in our successful summer season, and in particular to David Hughes, Bill and Nick who assisted with the transport arrangements to away matches.
Tony Lane
2009 Team Captain's Report
Once again, we knew summer had arrived when our opening match saw us eliminated from the Cup Competition in characteristic fashion. We started our season in the comfortable surroundings of the Northern Lawn Tennis Club at Didsbury. Due to a communication breakdown, our bottom board did not arrive , but fortunately Reyer Gerlagh had brought his 2 boys Peter and Joris, so he filled in on the bottom board. Even better, he secured a fine win and with victory for Joris, the Gerlagh family achieved a plus score on the night. Sadly, the team as a whole could not quite match it and we went out 3½:2½.
As regards the league, I reported last year that it appeared Rochdale were opting out of promotion and no teams were willing to be promoted from Division C, so that we would again be competing with the same teams. In actual fact, that was not the case and Bury replaced the promoted Rochdale while Denton and Salford were promoted to replace the second teams of Bury and Oldham. This worked out very well for us, as we started the league season with victories over both Salford and Bury and finished the season with a win at Denton. The only 2 teams we lost to were therefore the 2 teams who did remain in Division B, namely Stockport 2 and Chorlton 3. Again the matches were close affairs, with all wins bar our 4½:1½ victory over Salford being by the narrowest of margins 3½:2½, while our heaviest defeat was 4½:1½ at Stockport 2 with a narrow 3½:2½ defeat to Chorlton 3.
11 members played during the season. Bill and I played in all 6 matches, and Bill achieved 3 points to be joint top scorer of the season, while I was just behind with 2½ points. The other players to score 3 points were Joris who won all 3 matches he played in and Kurt who won 3 out of 4. Like Joris, Reyer's win at Didsbury in the Cup gave him a 100% record, while Peter won both his next 2 games after his defeat at Didsbury to give the Gerlagh family a very impressive aggregate score. They will be sorely missed following their return to the Netherlands.
Nick again battled manfully on top board securing 3 draws from his 4 matches, while Tom's persistence paid off with victory in his 5th and final match at Denton. The other members to play during the summer were Wayne Kranz , who helped out by playing at both Didsbury and Stockport , and Richard White and Callum McNulty who both drew the matches they played.
Overall, our results were good enough to secure us 2nd position as we finished with identical points to Stockport 2 but with 15½ points compared to their 15 points to secure 2nd on board count. The relegated Bury, won all 4 matches after their early defeat to ourselves to go back to Division A. We politely declined the opportunity to play in Division A , as we have been there before and it is not a pleasant experience!
We therefore ended the season pleased to maintain our position in B division and we look forward to the season ahead.
Tony Lane
2008 Team Captain's Report
We started our fourth successive year in Division B of the Summer League with the customary opening cup match. As often reported in prior years, the result once again saw us concentrating early on the league. Although last year's Round 1 elimination was a close affair with elimination to Eccles on board count, the same cannot be said this time around. We were well and truly hammered by a team from Oldham that massively outgraded us, and it was left to Steve Ward on the bottom board to prevent the whitewash with a fine win.
Our league fixtures were once again very close affairs, indicating that the B Division is an ideal league for us in the summer. Indeed, the first two matches against Stockport and Bury 2 were both even affairs, and it was only an unusual lapse by our bottom three boards at Chorlton 3 that resulted in our first defeat 4½:1½. This was followed by a further draw to the eventual champions Rochdale and the season ended with a flourish with a fine win at Oldham 2 3½:2½.
Again the number of participants in the 2008 summer league season reached double figures. Our strategy is to try and hold out on the top boards, and leave it up to the middle and lower order to carry us through to victory. As expected, Nick and I therefore had a torrid time on the top boards. I managed to draw 3 of my 5 games, whereas Nick drew one of his 4, but sadly neither of us tasted victory all summer long. The middle of the team proved more solid with Karl unbeaten in his two matches and Bill and Tom both gaining 50% from 5 and 4 matches respectively. In the lower order, David Merrifield was our top points scorer and most successful player with 3 wins out of 4 games, and Steve Ward had a very creditable performance with 2 wins from 4. The other people to play during the summer were Kurt Linke, Callum McNulty and Tom Hague with 4, 3 and 1 appearance respectively.
The 2009 season is now under way and with Rochdale opting out of promotion and Stockport 2 and Oldham 2 escaping relegation in the absence of any teams willing to be promoted from Division C, we find ourselves competing with the same teams again in the current campaign.
2007 Team Captain's Report
I could report that we finished third for the third successive season in Division B of the Summer League. However, you may recall last year that we were disputing the official position in the 2006 season, as our records indicated we had defeated Bury 2, 3½:2½ as opposed to the official records that had credited us with a draw. I am pleased to say that after a year of lobbying for the correct result to be reflected in the Summer League records, our victory over Bury 2 has now been confirmed and the additional point earned has been sufficient to secure for us the B Division Championship for 2006 on board count. As pointed out last year, both Stockport 2 and Chorlton 3 who now move to second and third in the league in that year, both opted to remain in B Division in 2007 and this would also have been our preference. However, it is nice to know that the trophies are currently being engraved and our name will appear as 2006 Division B Champions. Our third place finish last year was therefore not quite as impressive, but we were in fact only one win away from catching Chorlton 3 at the top of the table.
As usual, the season started with a cup match, and as is often the case saw us concentrating early on the league. The cup match at Eccles was a close affair, finishing 3:3, but as our wins were on the lower boards we were eliminated on board count. Our league fixtures started with a reversal of fortunes against Bury 2 from the position that had secured us the 2006 title. This time they won 3½:2½. However, we were able to follow that up with a resounding 4½:1½ victory over the eventual champions Chorlton 3, who went on to win all their other 4 matches. Our remaining 3 matches were all close fought affairs, with a 3½:2½ victory over Oldham 2, a defeat by the same score to Stockport 2 and finally a 4:2 victory against Urmston who having been promoted the season before were relegated in 2007. In fact they swapped positions once more with Rochdale.
We just about managed double figures in the number of participants in the 2007 Summer League season. Tom and myself played in all 6 matches and were relatively successful with 4 and 3 points respectively. We suffered a little on the higher boards from Richard and Nick not being available as much as in prior years. Nick secured 2 draws on top board from his 3 games and Richard had a win and a draw from his 2 matches. Karl and Bill filled in admirably with Bill playing 5 of the 6 matches and persistence paying off with a win at the last one at Urmston. Karl secured 2 wins from his 3 matches. The top points scorer and most successful player last season was Kurt who went through the season unbeaten finishing with 4 out of 5 points. David Hughes, Graham Bird and David Merrifield were the other people to appear during the summer with 3, 2 and 1 appearances respectively.
The 2008 season is now underway and with Chorlton 3 again opting out of promotion, the 6 teams competing in the league reverts to those playing in our 2006 championship year, with Rochdale again replacing Urmston.
2006 Team Captain's Report
Last season, following our relegation from Division A, we were not that far off from being promoted back to the top Division finishing third in Division B. The outcome of the 2006 season, at least in the eyes of the organisers, was an identical finish with a third position secured just one point behind Stockport 2 and Chorlton 3. However, I have to report that the official position is currently being disputed as we have been credited with a 3½:2½ defeat at the hands of Bury 2, whereas our records indicate that the match was drawn. If the latter proves to be correct, the additional point would bring us level with the top two teams, and our board count should be sufficient to secure the championship. This would be very worrying, if we were forced to play in A Division this year, as there is a significant gulf in the Summer League between A and B Divisions. However, both Stockport 2 and Chorlton 3 opted to remain in B Division and this would clearly have been our option, even if we had officially secured the title. However, the query over the Bury result is currently being pursued, as it would be nice to hold the trophy even though we opted not to be promoted.
The season started with a Cup match against Bury's first team, where we struggled and lost convincingly 5½:½. Our first league match was against Bury's second team, which is the subject of the disputed outcome, but obviously proved to be a much more appropriate level of opposition than their first team. As we believe the Bury match was a draw, we consider ourselves to be unbeaten in the league, as we followed that result with a victory at Chorlton 3, a draw at Oldham 2, and a victory and draw at home to Rochdale and Stockport 2 respectively.
Although eleven players played in the Summer League, Kurt Linke and Dan Thompson played only one game each. Of the other nine players, Dave Bryan and Nick Lowe struggled on the top boards, but all other seven players scored 50% or more. Daniel, Graham and myself all achieved 50%, while Tom, Richard, Bill and David achieved between 58% and 75%. Tom and Nick played in every game. Last year Tom also played in every match and had scored an impressive 3½ points from his six games. After four games of the currently campaign he had just 1½ points, but victories in the last two matches ensured he matched last year's impressive performance.
The 2007 season has now just commenced and with none of the teams opting for promotion, there is just one change to the opposition with Urmston's first team replacing the relegated first team from Rochdale.
2005 Team Captain's Report
If you recall, we entered last season with some trepidation on the back of a relegation from Division A, as the last time that had happened in 1998, we followed it up with another relegation to Division C. However, in line with the confidence I expressed at the last AGM, we avoided a repeat of that double relegation blow and comfortably consolidated our position in Division B with 5 points from our 5 games and a positive board count of 16:15, finishing third ahead of Bury 2 and both other first teams from Rochdale and Urmston.
As usual, the season kicked off with a cup match. We were narrowly beaten 3½:2½ to one of the top clubs in the Summer League, Chorlton. Our league campaign then got off to a poor start with a 4:2 defeat at Rochdale when Jonathan Fish, our top board, was unfortunately involved in a car accident on his way to the game resulting in a crucial default. Fortunately, Jonathan emerged unscathed but regrettably was unable to play in any more of our games that Summer.
Tom Tomkins was an ever present and scored an impressive 3½ points from his 6 games. Another 5 players played 4 matches. Of these David Bryan, David Merrifield, David Hughes and myself all managed to score 50% or more and Nick Lowe narrowly missed out with 3 draws from his 4 games. The top percentage score from 3 games or more was Graham Bird who scored 2 points and was unbeaten throughout the summer. Other valuable contributions were made by Richard White, Kurt Linke, Daniel Sullivan and Karl Lockett.
After the Rochdale match, a victory by 4:2 against Urmston contributed to their downfall. We were then narrowly defeated 3½:2½ against Oldham 2, before drawing with Chorlton 2 and finishing strongly with a victory by the margin 4½:1½ against Bury 2 to secure our position in Division B.
We therefore look forward to the coming campaign when champions Chorlton 2's place is taken by newly promoted Chorlton 3 and relegated Stockport 2 take the place of Urmston 1.
2004 Team Captain's Report
Last summer was the first time in the Club's history that we completed a third successive season of topflight summer league chess in Division A. The previous season had been our most successful in the summer league, being the first time we had won twice in a season, which had enabled us to finish fourth in the table. Regrettably, we were unable to sustain this impressive performance and were relegated back to B Division where we joined the first teams of Rochdale and Urmston and second teams of Chorlton, Bury and Oldham for the current season's competition. However, the season did have its uplifting moments with another exciting cup run, resulting in narrow victories over Urmston and Eccles before semi-final defeat to Peoples by a score of 4½:1½. Peoples have become our bogey team in cup competitions. As you may recall they also defeated us in the final in 2002. Our elimination this year was much narrower than the score suggested with a number of hard fought games, and was notable for a tremendous board 1 victory by Jonathan Fish over the highly rated Alan Smith.
Our season started with a cup match at Urmston which we drew but won on elimination of the bottom board result. However, our success was followed by two league defeats by a margin of 4½:1½ to Chorlton, the ultimate champions, and Oldham. As there are only 6 teams in the division, the next two matches against the lower rated Swinton and Bury teams were crucial. We were given hope by a narrow victory 3½:2½ at Swinton but could only draw with Bury to leave us 3 points behind them with only our last game to play. The outcome of that was a 4:2 defeat to 3Cs, the result of which was academic with relegation already our fate. The season concluded with our cup semi-final exit at Peoples.
On the whole, despite the outcome, I consider we competed well in what is an extremely tough division. Our results were achieved without Andrew Walden who had been ever present the previous year achieving 2½ points from his 6 matches played on the top 2 boards. His absence was partially offset by the availability of Jonathan for 5 of the 8 league and cup matches we played, but such is the strength in the division that he was only able to add 1 draw against Bury to his victory at Peoples. Daniel Sullivan was also only available for 3 matches as his study at Keele University continued to disrupt his season. He helped us out with a couple of draws on the top boards. We also benefited from the summer league debut season of Dave Bryan who picked up a win and a draw and more importantly enabled Nick Lowe and myself to play further down the order where we were able to both achieve 3½ points from 8 and 7 games respectively. Graham Bird matched my percentage score with 2 points from 4 games and Tom Tomkins was the top percentage performer with 2 wins out of 3 in a very successful debut season for him. In addition to the above, Kurt Linke, David Hughes and David Merrifield all tasted victory during the season, bringing our representative players for the season up to 10.
The last time we were relegated from Division A was 1998 when we lost all 6 matches and were relegated the very next year to Division C before storming back to the top flight with 2 successive promotions. With our current squad I would hope we could consolidate our position in Division B this coming season and avoid a repeat of the double relegation blow of 1998/99.
2003 Team Captain's Report
Last Summer we had the pleasure of playing in Division A of the summer league for the second successive year. This was a first, as our history in this league is to finish in the promotion or relegation positions and we are inclined to move through Divisions A to C on a bit of a roller coaster ride. We were hoping to build upon our best ever performance achieved in 2002, when we registered our first ever win in Division A and preserved our elite status by courtesy of the League deciding to relegate only one team as opposed to two previously. That season had been further boosted by a narrow defeat in the Cup Final to Peoples as opposed to our normal first round elimination. Although we reverted to type as far as the cup competition was concerned losing 3½:2½ in the first round to Chorlton, I am pleased to say that we did indeed build upon our earlier achievement by registering two victories from the five league games played to finish fourth in the table enabling us to look forward to our third successive season of top flight summer league chess.
I have to say that for a large part of the summer we anticipated the worst and relegation loomed large after the first three matches. These resulted in a 4:2 defeat to 3Cs, a 4½:1½ defeat at Oldham and another 4:2 defeat to Chorlton. However, these teams proved to be the stronger opposition finishing first, second and third respectively at the end of the season. The turning point, as ever, came when I went on holiday and came back to find we had stormed to an impressive 5½:½ victory at Manchester University. This was followed by an exciting 3½:2½ victory over Swinton which resulted in us finishing 2 points clear of both Swinton and Manchester University with a record 4 points haul for the Club in this Division.
This success was achieved despite the absence of our most successful summer league player of 2002, Mike Donkin, who had played in all 10 league and cup matches that season and had remained unbeaten until the Cup final. However, we were well served by our youth policy with Daniel Sullivan achieving the best percentage score with 3½ points from his 4 games and Jonathan Fish winning both his league matches on the top board and failing only in the cup match. They were well supported on the higher boards by Andrew Walden who was our only every present and achieved 2½ points from his 6 matches played on either boards 1 or 2. Nick Lowe was almost unbeaten, grinding out 4 draws from the 5 games he played. Further down the boards Ian Pratley and David Hughes made impressive debuts with 2½ points from 4 games and 2 points from 3 games respectively. Once again the Club was well represented by 12 different players during the season. The above mentioned were supplemented by myself, Richard, Graham, Karl, Kurt and Dan.
The 2004 campaign will again be spent in the company of just 5 other top teams, the only change from last year being the promotion of Bury to replace Manchester University. We look forward to improving still further upon our highly creditable recent past performances.